|
Crederi: In What Do You
Believe?–
Erev Rosh Hashanah (5769) |
|
|
Anshe Chesed Fairmount
Temple – Beachwood, Ohio
Rabbi
Arturo Kalfus |
|
|
There is anxiety and fear tonight. As you may know the
bailout vote in congress failed today. The market was down 777 points.
Although our currency may say, “in God we trust”, too
often, we have put our trust in our currency, rather than in God.
In Latin the word Crederi means “to believe”. I find
it so compelling that during the discussions in the last few weeks about
our economic and financial crisis, we have used expressions like: the
country is losing its credit worthiness, or citizens have lost their
credit, or our financial institutions have abused their credit. What in
fact we have been saying, if we knew this Latin derivative, is that our
nation’s near economic collapse is not only one based on lack or abuse of
credit, but is founded on a lack of faith. Let me put it in another way:
The economic and financial crisis we are experiencing is not one that has
to do only with the need for regulation and accountability, but one
that has to do with the things in which we choose to put our faith.
Financial and political leaders have worshiped our
monetary system as if it were a religion. It is not coincidental that much
of our Talmud deals with issues of conducting one’s business honestly –
after all, the temptation to focus on the profit alone is always a timeless
and oh-so-human temptation. Using honest scales is certainly something we
hope God will do in these days of Judgement! Shouldn’t we do the same when
dealing with each other?
The systemic failure in our economy may take us into
an abyss. Our personal and financial future is unknown but looking very
scary. It seems that everyone will pay, even if we do not know it yet.
Retirees and those about to retire will pay. Taxpayers will suffer. Home
owners will suffer. Businesses will suffer. College graduates will suffer.
We are all going to be poorer as a society..
Robert Reich, former secretary of labor, said that all
of us need to rebuild trust. He says the main problem is the collapse of
trust. If investors stop trusting promises, the markets can’t function. It
turns out that many of the promises weren’t worth the paper they were
written on. All it took, Secretary Reich said, were a few broken promises
for the whole system to break down.
While the professionals and elected officials are
trying to resolve this crisis, we need to review what has happened from a
broader perspective. Essentially: In what have we put all our trust?
Where have we invested, not financially, but where have we deposited our
trust and hopes? And
why can a financial shakedown dislodge so many of us
this deeply? We are experiencing, I believe, a question of Crederi, a
question of belief. But it is not just narrowly a belief in certain
financial transactions, whether they were done appropriately or not. This
crisis should lead us to ask much broader questions about our beliefs.
High Holy days is a time in our calendar that we ought
to take a step back and question our values and decisions. It is a time for
personal introspection but it is also a time for inquiry into larger issues.
Rosh HaShanah is in fact Yom arat Olam, the anniversary of the creation of
the world according to our Rabbis. Our responsibilities of review and
re-commitment are much larger than personal ones at this time.
We have let down future generations. We have put
our energies in consumption and our entire society has been left vulnerable.
I will never forget one of the first presidential reactions after 9/11.
After such a huge national crisis, out current president encouraged us, to
consume, to go to the movies and the malls and spend. What a huge
disappointment it was to hear that piece of advice. It was an opportunity
totally missed to bring our country together for a higher purpose and a
common destiny. American flags that were displayed in homes, cars and
businesses as an expression of solidarity, quickly disappeared, and the
spirit of consumption and competition and greed returned to the marketplace
as if nothing much had occurred.
The “ME First” philosophy got us into this problem.
Will we finally learn enough to truly change our priorities, to sincerely
and substantially mend our ways? This economic crisis is not an innocent
accident. It is the fruit of a great deal of injustice. Private profit
and what was good for me, was more important than the common good.
Materialism was better than our society’s health. Material worth was
thought to be more important than character, integrity and generosity. Jim
Wallis, a leader in interfaith relations, summarized this well: “The
behavior of too many on Wall Street is a violation of Biblical ethics. The
teachings of Christianity, Judaism and other faiths condemn the greed,
selfishness and cheating...”
If our society would aim toward the common good,
businesses will have a much higher degree of social responsibility. Instead
of more de-regulation we would have had more service. From our
over emphasis with individual rights, we would emphasize more cooperative
efforts and social accomplishments. We should not be only about prosperity
and opportunity, we should be in favor of the common interest. Franklin
Roosevelt, responding to a previous economic crisis said: “The measure of
the restoration lies in the extent to which we apply social values
more noble, than mere monetary profit” Or the famous John Kennedy’s “ask not
what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country”. At
the end, it is having a particular Crederi, a particular faith in our
common potential to do good and oppose cynicism.
The philosopher Plato, in antiquity, said it well:
“Justice is neither the right of the strong nor the advantage of the
stronger, but the right of the best and the advantage of the whole
community”.
What happens when we do not act this way? Dt 24:14
You shall not abuse a needy and destitute laborer, whether a Jew or a non
Jew.
In our own Jewish community, many of us have been
quite ashamed at what occurred in the Kosher plant in Postville, Iowa. A few
months ago, Agriprocessors, the largest kosher slaughterhouse in North
America was raided by the government. They arrested hundreds of illegal
immigrants and they also found tremendous abuses. Underage workers, sexual
abuse, people forced to work under substandard conditions and of course,
mistreatment of animals. The company certified Kosher meat but paid little
attention to human rights abuses. Justice was nowhere to be found.
The philosopher Abraham Joshua Heschel once asked the
question: “Why is it only required for butcher shops to be under religious
supervision? Why not insist that banks, factories and those who deal in real
estate require hekshers and be operated according to religious laws? When a
drop of blood is found in an egg, we abhor the idea of eating the egg, but
often there is more than one drop of blood in a dollar or a lira and we fail
to remind people constantly of the teachings of our tradition”.
In Dt 16 it is written: Tzedek tzedk tirdof...Justice,
justice you shall pursue. It is a simple but powerful imperative taught by
our Torah. Like Moses standing up to oppression, Judaism teaches us to
not be indifferent or silent when injustice occurs.
Lo tuchal lehitalem, “do not remain indifferent”.
When God question’s Cain saying, “Where is your brother?” Cain’s answer is
Hashomer Achi Anochi? “Am I my brother’s keeper?” In the text, God does not
reply. The Rabbis teach that there is no divine response because the answer
is too obvious to need one. Torah is teaching us that yes, we should be
responsible for what happens besides our immediate circle of family and
friends. “Am I my brother’s keeper?” Of course you are! As we all are.
We find ourselves in a time of instability – our
economy is shaky, our nation’s future is very unclear. In great part, we
find ourselves in this dilemma due to individual, self centered thirst for
profit. What we can learn from these difficult times is what we need to do
to improve our future and the future of our children. We must turn away
from individual needs as the top priority and re-dedicate ourselves for the
communal good.
So in these times of crisis, never loose your own
integrity. Instead we must act in the manner of Aaron Feuerstein, the
owner of a plant in Lawrence Mass., who when a fire raged through and
destroyed the plant, he continued paying his employees. He was under no
obligation to do so. This fire put 3,000 people out of work. When Feurstein
was asked why he would jeopardize his family fortune is such a way, he
answered simply. He had been taught by his parents to put people before
profits, which is exactly what he did after the fire nearly destroyed
the 90 year old company.
Instead of collecting his fire insurance money and selling
his company to make a profit, or moving it overseas where wages are a lot less,
he stayed in Lawrence, Mass. And told his workers that he would pay each of them
a month’s salary of $12.50 an hour. Not only did he do this for one month but
for three, costing him millions of dollars.
One worker and his wife said this about it:
“When he did it the first time, I was surprised, the
second time was a shock. The third...well, it was unrealistic to think he would
do it again. It was the third time that brought tears to everyone’s eyes.”
After coming out of bankruptcy, Mr. Feuerstein was
interviewed on 60 Minutes. He was asked, if he knew how things would have
played out, would he have still done the same thing? His answer was immediate:
“Yes, it was the right thing to do”. We can learn from Aaron Feurstein.
Never lose your integrity, especially at a time of crisis.
We also need to remember what Maimonides taught us- our
first obligation is to tend to our own families. The Talmud made it clear: Kol
Israel arevim ze ba ze, All of Israel is responsible for one another. On this
RH, I am asking that we should expand our concern for our own congregants
that in this time of uncertainty and crisis may need our help.
I am making an appeal for help! I am asking those who are
therapists or social workers to give up a few hours during this year to help
congregants in need on a confidential basis, for doctors and other medical
personnel to give up a few hours during this coming year to help families whose
insurance has run out or have some other medical need. I am asking for lawyers
to give some hours pro bono to provide legal advise to those individuals or
families who may be in jeopardy of losing their homes. I am asking accountants
to help with financial tax advice to those within our Temple community who are
in trouble. I am asking employers to register with the Temple, offering possible
employment opportunities for individuals who are unemployed and might be in
danger of losing everything they have. Congregants in need of work might be
matched with those who may have a job opening.
Each member who has other skills and/ or abilities should
volunteer as well. We may need babysitting, tutors, drivers, food deliverers,
hospital and home visitors, all types of talent will be welcome. We need to help
out for we are an extended family and some of us are experiencing hard times.
Whatever your talents and your profession, I would like to hear from you, so
please call me. We will publish in our bulletin what services are available to
be provided in a confidential manner.
My colleague R. Irwin Kula, wrote:
“Every religious and spiritual wisdom tradition suggests
that great moments of collective trauma or suffering are also invitations- not
for flight (turning inwards to simply protect ourselves) or fight (blaming
others)- but to honestly self-reflect, introspect and grow. Obviously,
some people are guiltier than others for this economic crisis but in an
interdependent reality, all are responsible... What did I do that may
have contributed to where we collectively find ourselves?
And let’s stop having faith in the economy and begin to
have faith in each other- trusting that the happiness that comes from greed is
transient at best, while happiness that comes from giving, serving and even
sacrificing for each other is far more enduring and credit worthy.
In these trying economic and financial times, we need to
review, not our credit, but our Crederi, our faith. We do not need more
consumption, we need more service. We need to use this RH as an opportunity to
have a new faith – one based on loving-kindness , where we can feel that by
extending ourselves to others who are in need, we are not being considered soft,
naive or foolish.”
On this Rosh Hashanah as we stand before God and pray to
be inscribed in the book of sustenance and well being, let’s remember: never
give up on ethical behavior, let’s remember to believe that we were created to
be an Am Kadosh, a holy people whose purpose is to bring decency and sanity to a
world that is in moral disarray.
May the new year bring for each of us strength to
withstand the economic uncertainties and the moral courage not to lose our
spiritual compasses which have guided us and kept us safe throughout the years.
Ken ihie ratzon,
May this be God’s will,
Amen.
|